March 15 marked not just the anniversary of the country’s lockdown, it also marked a near-360-degree return to policies enforced in 2020.
US-based Filipino journalist Barnaby Lo was one of the first to point out how the government’s policy of detaining quarantine violators was flawed.
Iyon mga nahuhuling lumalabag sa curfew bakit hindi na lang pauwiin? Bakit pagkukumpulin pa para sermonan o parusahan? Edi lalong nagkahawaan. Ay, parang nasabi ko na ito last year. 😂 Walang natutunan sa loob ng isang taon.
— Barnaby Lo 吳宗鴻 (@barnabychuck) March 16, 2021
Lo argues that protocol violators, particularly those who were out between 10 pm and 5 am last Monday, March 15, should have just been told off on the spot and promptly sent home.
“Why gather them in one place to either tell them off or punish them? They might end up spreading the virus,” Lo tweeted in Filipino.
He would also criticize the national government as this has been the policy since March 2020.
This tweet would have likely been in response to reports of cities intensifying efforts to arrest curfew violators, like this one from Pasay City.
WATCH: Pasay City intensifies efforts in arresting curfew violators as part of the city's move to stop the spread of COVID-19.
As of March 16, the city has arrested 448 curfew violators @cnnphilippines pic.twitter.com/hctVfjdysR
— Tristan Nodalo (@TristanNodalo) March 16, 2021
According to Pasay City Police chief Cesar Paday-os, Filipinos give a myriad of reasons to go out even if they know that a curfew is in effect.
“Marami pa rin po ang nagpapalusot kahit alam na nila na may bagong curfew na pinatutupad ay talagang lumalabas pa rin sila ng bahay para gumala kahit walang importanteng dahilan,” Pasay city police chief Col. Cesar Paday-os said in a statement @cnnphilippines
— Tristan Nodalo (@TristanNodalo) March 16, 2021
Healthcare experts, on the other hand, would call out both the national and local governments for implementing curfews and liquor bans instead of improving contact-tracing and other medical-based solutions to battle the pandemic.
Doctors from the Healthcare Professionals Alliance vs. COVID-19 say that curfews and liquor bans are not the only solutions to stop the surge.
"Let's stop blaming the people. Pagod na sila kaka-comply, pero they were forced to go out," the group said. @cnnphilippines
— Tristan Nodalo (@TristanNodalo) March 16, 2021
Netizens agreed with health experts, who have also pointed out how the government’s general policies have not yet changed since 2020.
https://twitter.com/altbohol/status/1371737411894398977
— ruralite 苺 (@elmitanyo) March 16, 2021
https://twitter.com/nickotalavera_/status/1371735047485620227
No. The manner they round up curfew violators is a super-spreader event in itself.
— Sam Yunono™ 🇵🇭🎶🏀🏐 (@SamYunono) March 16, 2021
Some netizens even called out certain government officials who attended gatherings, which at the time were still banned because of stricter health protocols.
https://twitter.com/hueljay/status/1371675357082841088
Some netizens, however, did raise a good point: people who were out at night, i.e. “drunkards, partygoers, and stoners”, were harder to control.
Trying to be a smart post? The curfew is for violators of protocols at night. They are the ones harder to control – drunkards, partygoers, stoners. https://t.co/9ZHa7NTO7Q
— ana ~ # rm -rf / (@ana_zero_4_3) March 15, 2021
However, this would be proven false as most of the curfew violators looked sober—even as they were kept in make-shift detention centers until the end of the curfew.
One netizen even harked back a major event early on in the lockdown: the unfortunate death of a retired military man who had post traumatic stress disorder from his final tour of duty in Marawi.
Exactly. And the militarized mindset led to the shooting and killing of at least one with PTSD and the rounding up of quarantine/curfew violators only to be detained in an overcrowded prison or facility.
— Morbid Curiosity (@TatayDinong) March 15, 2021
Another netizen highlighted something worse: the chance of being detained for supposedly violating quarantine protocols, yet working in an industry that basically lives between 10 pm and 5 am—the business process outsourcing industry.
https://twitter.com/gnzls_mariane/status/1370924122897743874
To date, the government has not reevaluated their policy on health protocol violations as President Rodrigo Duterte had previously instructed local officials to detain them.
Duterte, however, would also show a bit of forward thinking as he insisted on purchasing face masks and giving them away to those who do not have them.
Face mask violations are some of the more common violations currently being shared on social media.